Files
yxxhero 16259008d5 feat: opt-in OpenTelemetry tracing and metrics (experimental) (#2769)
* feat(telemetry): add opt-in OpenTelemetry tracing (PR 1: lifecycle + root span)

Implements the first increment of docs/proposals/otel-tracing.md (#2767):

- pkg/telemetry: SDK setup from standard OTEL_* env vars (autoexport for
  exporter selection, env-driven sampler/propagators, OTEL_SDK_DISABLED),
  command-span lifecycle, no-op-by-default accessors
- --otel-tracing flag / HELMFILE_OTEL_TRACING env switch
- root span "helmfile <command>" with file/environment/selectors/exit_code
  attributes; TRACEPARENT-based remote-parent extraction for CI correlation
- shutdown flush on both normal-exit and signal paths (nil-safe, 5s bound)
- app.New derives its context from telemetry.CommandContext()
  (Background-identical when tracing is disabled)
- docs: otel.md user guide, experimental-features entry, design proposal
- tests: hermetic unit tests, app context-contract pinning, flag registration

Telemetry problems never fail a run: exporter misconfiguration and export
errors degrade to disabled with a warning. When disabled, behavior and
performance are identical to before (no-op tracer, no goroutines, no
network).

Refs: #2767, #2758
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* feat(telemetry): trace every external process + trace-context bridges (PR 2)

Implements the second increment of docs/proposals/otel-tracing.md (#2767):

- pkg/helmexec/span.go: one span per external process started by helmfile
  (helm invocations, hooks, plugin execs) at the ShellRunner choke point —
  helm.exec (with helm.subcommand) vs os.exec, with redacted exec.args,
  exec.exit_code, and error status on failure
- pkg/helmexec/redact.go: shared argument redaction with two profiles;
  legacy is byte-identical to the historical exit-error behavior (existing
  goldens unchanged), strict (spans) additionally covers --set=k=v and
  credential flags; exit_error.go now uses the shared helper
- orphan-trace bridges with bit-identical cancellation semantics
  (context.WithoutCancel of the command context): both kubedog call sites
  (state.go) and hook execution (event.Bus gains an optional Ctx consumed
  by its default runner; state.go sets it, nil falls back to TODO as before)
- OTLP end-to-end test (in-process httptest receiver, no external
  collector): span export, error status/exit code, redaction, and
  parent-linkage to the command span
- docs/otel.md updated to the now-traced surface

Verified end-to-end with the console exporter: helmfile template on a
local chart yields the command span plus helm.exec spans for helm
version/dependency/template, all nested under it.

Refs: #2767
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* feat(telemetry): state-loading and hook spans (PR 3a)

Implements the third increment of docs/proposals/otel-tracing.md (#2767):

- helmfile.discover_states around findDesiredStateFiles and helmfile.load
  around loadDesiredStateFromYamlWithBaseDir; both cover all callers
  (incl. nested helmfiles) with no signature changes
- helmfile.render / helmfile.parse children per document part, parented
  through a traceCtx field on the unexported desiredStateLoader struct
  (set once at its single construction site)
- helmfile.hook span per hook execution: Trigger's per-hook body extracted
  into runHook (readability win on its own), the hook's subprocess span
  nests under it via a per-hook ctx-swapped ShellRunner clone
  (cancellation unchanged — Bus.Ctx never carries cancellation by contract)
- pkg/telemetry/otlptest: shared in-process OTLP/HTTP receiver harness,
  now used by helmexec, event, and app span tests
- golden span-tree test at the app layer (root -> discover -> load ->
  render/parse, via the exectest fake helm) and a hook-span nesting test
- nil-ctx guard for App literals built directly by tests (App.spanParentCtx)

Verified end-to-end with the console exporter: a template run over a
gotmpl state file with a prepare hook yields the full tree with the hook's
os.exec nested under helmfile.hook.

Refs: #2767
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* feat(telemetry): per-release spans nested under the load span (PR 3b)

Implements the per-release increment of docs/proposals/otel-tracing.md
(#2767) — spans nest command -> load -> release -> helm exec:

- helmexec.HelmContext gains an optional Ctx carrying the per-release span
  context; the execer's new execWithContext funnel consumes it via a
  per-call runner clone (runnerWithCtx) so the shared, cached execer is
  never mutated across concurrent workers. The seven Interface methods
  that take a HelmContext (Sync/Diff/ReleaseStatus/List/DecryptSecret/
  Delete/Test) route through it; nil Ctx behaves exactly as before.
  exec() lost its always-nil override parameter on the way (unparam).
- pkg/state/span.go: SetTraceContext + startReleaseSpan/endReleaseSpan
  helpers (release/namespace/chart/labels attributes, sorted for stable
  output); a typed-nil guard (releaseErrAsError) avoids the classic
  nil-pointer-in-interface trap on *ReleaseError.
- release spans in the worker loops: SyncReleases, DiffReleases,
  DeleteReleasesForSync, PrepareCharts, and iterateOnReleases (status/
  delete/test via a new verb parameter); their HelmContext is stamped with
  the release span context where one is built.
- pkg/app sets st.SetTraceContext(loadCtx) right after loading a state
  file, rooting all per-release spans under helmfile.load.
- bridged one more detached tracking call found on the way
  (trackReleaseIfEnabled's context.Background in the sync worker).
- golden test: release span present, nested under load, correct
  attributes; unit test for the runnerWithCtx clone semantics.

Verified with the console exporter: helmfile template yields
release.prepare(demo) under load with full attributes.

Refs: #2767
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* feat(telemetry): nest status/delete/test execs under their release spans

Completes the per-release exec nesting for the iterateOnReleases-based
loops (docs/proposals/otel-tracing.md §4.4 phase 2): the do closures now
receive the release span context and stamp it into their HelmContext, so
helm status/delete/test subprocess spans nest under
helmfile.release.<verb> like sync/diff already did.

- scatterGatherReleases/iterateOnReleases/doWithReleaseSpan: do gains a
  context parameter (the release span context)
- ReleaseStatuses/DeleteReleases/TestReleases closures stamp
  HelmContext.Ctx from it
- integration test with a real execer (version-probe shim binary): the
  release's status subprocess nests under helmfile.release.status, same
  trace, with helm.subcommand=status

This also makes the otel.md claim ("upgrade, diff, delete, status, test
nested under the release span") fully accurate.

Refs: #2767
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* feat(telemetry): OTel metrics — helm exec duration and release results (PR 4)

Implements the metrics increment of docs/proposals/otel-tracing.md
(#2767) on the same provider, switch, and resource as traces:

- pkg/telemetry/metrics.go: helmfile.helm.exec.duration histogram
  (subcommand, success) and helmfile.release.count counter (verb,
  result). Instruments come from the otel global meter, so recording at
  call sites is branch-free no-op when telemetry is disabled.
- Setup builds the resource once and installs both providers; reader
  selection delegates to autoexport (OTEL_METRICS_EXPORTER: otlp |
  console | prometheus | none), the OTLP reader's interval honors
  OTEL_METRIC_EXPORT_INTERVAL (read by the SDK). Shutdown flushes both
  providers (errors.Join). StartCommandSpan now carries the meter
  provider across state transitions (fixes a nil-shutdown panic).
- helmexec: finishExecSpan records exec duration for helm binaries;
  state: endReleaseSpan counts release outcomes for sync/diff/delete/
  status/test/prepare (diff counted as success when no hard error).
- otlptest: recorder routes by OTLP path (/v1/traces vs /v1/metrics)
  and decodes metrics; new FindMetric helper.
- tests: metrics recorded as no-op when disabled, provider enabled with
  the none exporter, degradation on an invalid metrics exporter, and an
  integration assertion (status exec duration datapoint + one successful
  release.count) in the shim-based state test.

Verified with the console exporter: helmfile template emits
helmfile.helm.exec.duration per subcommand (version/dependency/
template) and helmfile.release.count{verb=prepare,result=success}=1.

Refs: #2767
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* docs: complete OTel documentation coverage

- docs/cli.md: --otel-tracing in the CLI reference help block (verbatim
  from the cobra output)
- CHANGELOG.md: [Unreleased] Added entry for tracing + metrics
- docs/index.md: Observability highlight linking docs/otel.md
- docs/proposals/otel-tracing.md: add OTEL_METRICS_EXPORTER /
  OTEL_METRIC_EXPORT_INTERVAL rows to the env-var table and note the
  periodic reader + bounded metric cardinality in §7

Refs: #2767
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* fix: drop unused id parameter from parsePart (unparam)

The id parameter was never used inside the span wrapper; the caller's id
variable is still used for the render calls and error messages.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* fix(telemetry): address review — redaction gaps, kubedog valve, phantom metrics

Addresses all Copilot review comments on #2769:

Security (span payloads):
- exec.args: positional arguments are additionally passed through
  helmexec.RedactedURL, so credentials embedded in chart/repository URLs
  (AddRepo, RegistryLogin, OCI refs) are masked exactly like log output
- release spans sanitize helmfile.chart the same way
- error statuses no longer embed raw errors (which contain rendered
  commands, arguments, and subprocess output): the command span, release
  spans, hook spans, and exec spans now use generic descriptions; the
  concrete exit code remains an attribute, and RecordError on the root
  span is dropped

Correctness:
- kubedog safety valve restored: execWithContext now attaches the
  per-release span into the runner's own context instead of replacing it,
  so trackHandle.Cancel() can interrupt a wedged helm again and app
  cancellation semantics stay exactly as before the PR
- diff release spans/metrics: real failures are recorded (exit code 2
  "changes detected" still counts as success); previously every diff was
  exported as successful
- skipped releases no longer emit phantom spans and inflate
  helmfile.release.count: iterateOnReleases callers pass a skip predicate
  (skipUndesired for status/test; delete deletes undesired releases and
  passes nil)
- Setup shuts down the already-constructed tracer provider (bounded) when
  the metrics provider fails, instead of abandoning its batch goroutine

Tests: URL redaction cases (masked/untouched), spanAttachedContext
preserves the runner cancellation chain while attaching the caller's
span, skipUndesired, and a failing-hook span asserting the generic
message.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* fix: lint — restore nolint placement and avoid nil context literal

- the skipUndesired insertion had displaced the // nolint: unparam
  directive off iterateOnReleases (helm param is intentionally unused
  there); also fixes a skipDesired/skipUndesired comment typo
- use a typed nil in TestSpanAttachedContext (staticcheck SA1012)

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* fix(telemetry): address review round 2 — remote-ref redaction, wrapper helm binaries, hook release attribution

Addresses all 6 new review comments on #2769:

Security (remote references):
- new helmexec.RedactedRef sanitizes go-getter style references for
  telemetry: forced-form prefixes (git::, s3::) preserved, whole URL
  userinfo masked (usernames carry tokens too), credential-bearing query
  parameters masked using pkg/remote's heuristic (token/password/secret/
  key/signature). Applied to helmfile.file (command span), helmfile.path
  (discover_states), helmfile.chart (release spans), and exec.args —
  log-time RedactedURL is untouched so log output is unchanged

Correctness:
- wrapper helm binaries (--helm-binary custom names) are now classified
  as helm operations by an explicit context marker stamped in the execer
  funnel, instead of the executable-basename heuristic; the same
  classification gates helmfile.helm.exec.duration, so the metric no
  longer misses wrapper invocations (classifyExec)
- release-scoped hooks (presync/postsync/preuninstall/postuninstall/
  cleanup in the sync/delete/diff workers) now attach their helmfile.hook
  spans to the active helmfile.release.* span via a variadic parent on
  the trigger functions; global hooks keep the command context and all
  29 existing call sites compile unchanged; hook cancellation stays
  detached (WithoutCancel) as before
- signal-terminated runs (Shutdown with exitCode 130/143 and nil error)
  now mark the command span with error status, consistent with their
  nonzero exit code

Tests: RedactedRef table (forced forms, userinfo, s3/token query params,
untouched cases), classifyExec marker case, hookTraceContext parent
attribution + non-cancellability + fallback.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* fix(telemetry): address review round 3 — redaction corner cases, value runners

Addresses 5 of the 6 new review comments on #2769 (the sixth — an
unused strings import in exit_error.go — is a false positive: Indent
still uses strings.Split/Builder and the package compiles):

- RedactArgs read the previous token from the progressively redacted
  output, so {--set, --set-string, secret} leaked the secret
  (the masked value hid the following flag). Read the previous token
  from the original input, restoring the legacy contract for adjacent
  secret flags
- RedactedRef fails closed for malformed references: URL-like refs with
  invalid percent escapes export a fully redacted value, and an
  unparseable query is dropped entirely instead of exported verbatim
- ShellRunner has value receivers, so a ShellRunner VALUE satisfies the
  Runner API; the helm marker stamping and the per-release span
  attachment now handle both value and pointer forms (matching
  WithContext), so value-runner callers keep release nesting and the
  helm.exec classification/metric

Regression tests: adjacent secret flags (legacy + strict), malformed
URL-like ref, malformed query, value-runner marker + span attachment.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* fix(telemetry): stamp the helm marker on the stdin funnel too

execStdIn (registry login, repo add) called the runner directly, so
wrapper --helm-binary names were misclassified as os.exec and omitted
from helmfile.helm.exec.duration on that path. The marking now goes
through a shared markHelmRunner helper (value and pointer ShellRunner
forms) used by both execution funnels.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* fix(telemetry): redact helm's --kube-token in strict profile

Helm's global --kube-token carries a bearer token; both the
two-argument and inline forms are now masked in span exec.args
(legacy exit-error output is untouched, matching its historical
behavior).

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* fix(telemetry): OTel metrics best-practice alignment

- helmfile.helm.exec.duration now declares explicit bucket boundaries
  tuned for seconds-scale helm invocations (5ms…600s); the SDK defaults
  are millisecond-oriented and lumped every sub-5s invocation — the
  common case — into the first bucket, defeating the histogram
- instruments are re-created under the installed provider with the
  instrumentation scope version stamped (Setup-time, race-free)
- helmfile.release.count declares the {release} curly-annotation unit
  per the metrics naming conventions

Tested end-to-end via the OTLP integration test: exported bounds are
the tuned set, units are asserted, and the scope carries the version.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* feat(telemetry): per-release duration metrics behind an opt-in switch

New helmfile.release.duration histogram (seconds, same tuned buckets)
with bounded dimensions by default (verb, result). Setting
HELMFILE_OTEL_METRICS_PER_RELEASE=true adds helmfile.release and
helmfile.namespace, answering "which release is slow" from dashboards:

- well-suited to bounded CI runs; long-lived centralized collection
  needs a backend capacity/TTL story (documented in docs/otel.md)
- per-release timing remains available in traces without the flag
- env read per call (release operations are low-frequency, and tests
  toggle it)

endReleaseSpan now takes the release and the operation start time; the
five worker-loop call sites pass them (doWithReleaseSpan, SyncReleases,
DeleteReleasesForSync, PrepareCharts, DiffReleases).

Verified end-to-end with the console exporter (default dims vs
per-release) and OTLP integration tests pinning both modes.

Refs: #2767, #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* refactor(telemetry): maintainability pass over the runner/metric plumbing

- StartCommandSpan copies the tracingState struct instead of enumerating
  fields by hand — that pattern dropped the meter provider once already
- the two value/pointer ShellRunner switches (helm marker, span
  attachment) are unified into one withRunnerCtx helper; the duplication
  caused two review rounds of value-form misses
- classifyExec derives the helm classification from the span name
  (helmExecSpanName constant) instead of returning a third parallel bool
- metrics: shared outcomeAttrs for the verb/result dimensions, and the
  bucket slice renamed to durationBuckets with a comment covering both
  histograms that use it

No behavior change; full -race suite green, lint clean.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* refactor(telemetry): consolidate test env lists, trace bridges, and hook prep; sync the design doc

Maintainability:
- HermeticEnvVars is now exported from pkg/telemetry (the owner of the
  env surface) and used by both telemetry tests and otlptest — the two
  copies had already drifted once (HELMFILE_OTEL_METRICS_PER_RELEASE
  needed updating in both)
- kubedogTraceContext and hookTraceContext were the same concept written
  twice; unified into traceOnlyContext(parent...) in span.go

Readability:
- runHook's nested kubectl rewrite extracted into prepareKubectlHook
  with guard-clause structure

Accuracy (docs ↔ code, drifted over five review rounds):
- §4.4 now describes the implemented mechanism: the release span is
  INJECTED into the runner's own context (preserving the kubedog safety
  valve) rather than the runner context being replaced, and helm
  classification is marker-based for wrapper binaries
- §5 exec span rows list the actual attributes incl. URL/query masking
- §6 strict profile documents RedactedRef, --kube-token, and the
  adjacent-token guarantee

No behavior change; full -race suite green, lint clean.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* refactor(telemetry): drop the dead noop state, relocate skipUndesired, sync user-facing accuracy

- tracingState.noop was dead weight in the enabled state and a
  copy-surface in every transition; a single package-level
  noopTracerProvider now backs Tracer while disabled
- skipUndesired moved next to doWithReleaseSpan in span.go, its only
  conceptual home (span/metric suppression, not run plumbing)
- accuracy: the package doc, --otel-tracing flag help,
  experimental-features entry, and CHANGELOG now all say tracing AND
  metrics and list the third instrument (helmfile.release.duration with
  the HELMFILE_OTEL_METRICS_PER_RELEASE opt-in) — these had drifted
  when the metric was added; the PR description's metric table is
  updated to match as well

No behavior change; full -race suite green (except the pre-existing
network-dependent TestStorage_resolveFile flake), lint clean.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* refactor(telemetry): flatten Setup, name the prefix bound, dedupe test fake; fix instrument-count drift

Readability/maintainability:
- Setup drops from 56 to 39 lines: provider construction (including the
  shutdown-tracer-on-meter-failure recovery) moves to newProviders in
  exporter.go next to the constructors it composes
- refredact's magic 16 becomes maxForcedFormPrefix with a comment
- span_test's hand-rolled fakeRunner removed in favor of the existing
  mockRunner (same package)

Accuracy:
- "Two instruments" wording survived in docs/otel.md and the design
  proposal §7 after helmfile.release.duration was added; both now say
  three and mention the per-release opt-in

No behavior change; full -race suite green (except the pre-existing
network flake), lint clean.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

* refactor(telemetry): co-locate span machinery, drop a dead export, fix docs nits

- the span plumbing helpers (markHelmExec, withRunnerCtx,
  markHelmRunner, spanAttachedContext) move from exec.go to span.go,
  next to the marker type and classifiers they serve — exec.go keeps
  only the funnel call sites
- otlptest.SpanNames was never used outside the package; unexported
- isHelmBinary's comment now states it is the FALLBACK classifier
  (funnel invocations are marker-classified), replacing the outdated
  "cosmetic distinction" framing from before the marker existed
- docs/otel.md: release-scoped hooks nest under their release span
  (added in review round 2, never documented)

No behavior change; full -race suite green, lint clean.

Refs: #2769
Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>

---------

Signed-off-by: yxxhero <aiopsclub@163.com>
2026-09-07 20:34:10 +08:00

111 lines
6.5 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# OpenTelemetry Tracing
Helmfile can export [OpenTelemetry](https://opentelemetry.io/) traces of a run, which is especially useful in CI/CD: see where time is spent, which helm invocations dominate, how label selectors fan out, and what to target for improvement.
Tracing is **experimental** and **off by default**. It currently emits the command-level root span, state-loading spans (discover/load/render/parse), one span per external process (helm invocations, hooks, plugin execs), per-hook spans, and per-release spans for the sync/diff/delete/status/test/prepare paths.
## Enabling
```bash
helmfile --otel-tracing -e production -l tier=backend apply
```
or via environment variable (handy for CI):
```bash
export HELMFILE_OTEL_TRACING=true
helmfile sync
```
`--otel-tracing` overrides `HELMFILE_OTEL_TRACING` when specified.
## Configuration
Everything beyond the on/off switch uses the standard [OpenTelemetry environment variables](https://opentelemetry.io/docs/specs/otel/configuration/sdk-environment-variables/); helmfile defines no telemetry-specific variables of its own.
| Variable | Default | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| `OTEL_EXPORTER_OTLP_ENDPOINT` | `http://localhost:4318` | OTLP endpoint; use `http://host:4317` for gRPC |
| `OTEL_EXPORTER_OTLP_PROTOCOL` | `http/protobuf` | or `grpc` |
| `OTEL_EXPORTER_OTLP_HEADERS` | — | e.g. `authorization=Bearer <token>` |
| `OTEL_TRACES_EXPORTER` | `otlp` | `otlp` \| `console` \| `none` |
| `OTEL_METRICS_EXPORTER` | `otlp` | `otlp` \| `console` \| `prometheus` \| `none` — see [Metrics](#metrics) |
| `OTEL_TRACES_SAMPLER` (+ `OTEL_TRACES_SAMPLER_ARG`) | `parentbased_always_on` | |
| `OTEL_SERVICE_NAME` | `helmfile` | |
| `OTEL_RESOURCE_ATTRIBUTES` | — | e.g. `cicd.pipeline=deploy,cicd.run_id=4821` |
| `OTEL_PROPAGATORS` | `tracecontext,baggage` | |
| `OTEL_SDK_DISABLED` | `false` | standard kill switch |
HTTP proxies (`HTTPS_PROXY`/`HTTP_PROXY`) are honored automatically by the Go runtime.
## Quick start without a collector
To inspect what would be exported, print spans as JSON on stdout:
```bash
OTEL_TRACES_EXPORTER=console helmfile --otel-tracing -l name=myrelease template
```
## Quick start with Jaeger
```bash
docker run --rm -p 16686:16686 -p 4318:4318 jaegertracing/all-in-one:latest
OTEL_EXPORTER_OTLP_ENDPOINT=http://localhost:4318 \
helmfile --otel-tracing -e production apply
# Open http://localhost:16686 and pick service "helmfile"
```
## What gets traced
The root span is named after the command (`helmfile apply`, `helmfile sync`, ...) and carries `helmfile.command`, `helmfile.file`, `helmfile.environment`, and `helmfile.selectors` attributes, plus `helmfile.exit_code` and the error (if any) at the end.
Every external process helmfile starts — each helm invocation, hook command, and plugin exec — gets its own span nested under the command span: `helm.exec` (with `helm.subcommand`) for helm binaries, `os.exec` otherwise, both carrying `exec.command`, redacted `exec.args`, and `exec.exit_code` on failure.
State loading is traced too: `helmfile.discover_states`, one `helmfile.load` per state file (including nested helmfiles), with `helmfile.render` and `helmfile.parse` children — rendering is frequently the hidden time sink. Each hook execution produces a `helmfile.hook` span (with `hook.event` and `hook.name`) that its subprocess span nests under — and release-scoped hooks (presync/postsync & co. within sync/diff/delete) nest under their release's span, keeping full release attribution.
Per-release spans (`helmfile.release.sync` / `.diff` / `.delete` / `.status` / `.test` / `.prepare`) carry the release name, namespace, chart, and labels, and nest under the state-file load span — with the release's helm subprocesses (upgrade, diff, delete, status, test) nested under the release span. The remaining loops (flag preparation, template/lint/unittest) are being added incrementally; see [the design proposal](proposals/otel-tracing.md) for the full taxonomy.
Secret-bearing command arguments (`--set`, `--set-file`, `--username`, `--password`, ...) are never recorded in span attributes — they are masked before export.
## Metrics
Tracing and metrics share the same switch and resource; metrics are exported through the standard metrics environment variables:
| Variable | Default | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| `OTEL_METRICS_EXPORTER` | `otlp` | `otlp` \| `console` \| `prometheus` \| `none` |
| `OTEL_METRIC_EXPORT_INTERVAL` | `60000` (ms) | periodic export interval; the final flush happens at exit |
Three instruments are emitted:
| Metric | Type | Attributes |
|---|---|---|
| `helmfile.helm.exec.duration` | histogram (seconds, buckets tuned for 5ms–600s helm invocations) | `subcommand`, `success` |
| `helmfile.release.duration` | histogram (seconds, same buckets) | `verb`, `result` — plus `helmfile.release` and `helmfile.namespace` when per-release metrics are enabled (below) |
| `helmfile.release.count` | counter (unit `{release}`) | `verb` (sync/diff/delete/status/test/prepare), `result` (success/error) |
### Per-release metrics (opt-in, high cardinality)
By default metric dimensions are bounded enumerations — release names never appear, so time-series count stays constant regardless of fleet size. If you need per-release durations on dashboards, opt in:
```bash
HELMFILE_OTEL_METRICS_PER_RELEASE=true helmfile --otel-tracing sync
```
This adds `helmfile.release` and `helmfile.namespace` to `helmfile.release.duration`. Time-series count then scales with your release fleet: well-suited to bounded CI runs, but long-lived centralized collection needs a backend capacity/TTL story. (Per-release timing is always available in traces, without this flag.)
Both dimensions are bounded enumerations — never release names — so metric cardinality stays constant regardless of fleet size. The instrumentation scope (`helmfile`) carries the helmfile version.
Inspect them without a collector with `OTEL_METRICS_EXPORTER=console`.
## CI trace correlation
If your CI system injects a W3C `TRACEPARENT` environment variable into jobs, helmfile joins that trace automatically, so helmfile spans appear inside your pipeline's trace.
## Troubleshooting
- **No spans arrive**: check `OTEL_EXPORTER_OTLP_ENDPOINT`/protocol match your collector (4318 for `http/protobuf`, 4317 for `grpc`); verify with `OTEL_TRACES_EXPORTER=console`.
- **Tracing breaks nothing**: exporter/sampler misconfiguration and export failures never fail a helmfile run; at worst you get no spans.
- **Still stuck?** Set `OTEL_SDK_DISABLED=false` explicitly and rerun with `--log-level debug`.