Files
maziggy 62a64006b8 fix(camera): stop /camera/stop from letting a second socket open (#2521)
The single-connection barrier from the last round was correct and was being
bypassed. shutdown_broadcaster() popped the broadcaster out of the registry
and only then awaited its teardown, so while the socket was still closing the
slot sat empty: a /camera/stream request landing in that window minted a
broadcaster with no predecessor and dialled port 6000 immediately. A page
reload fires /camera/stop and the new stream request concurrently, so a P1S
ended up holding two connections, kept feeding the orphan, and starved the
live viewer until its TCP keepalive reaped the dead one ~20 min later. The
stopped broadcaster now stays in the registry so the successor chains behind
its socket close.

The camera page also rendered the <img> src before the stream token arrived
whenever auth was disabled, then swapped it once the token landed — aborting
the in-flight request and issuing a second one. With auth off both reached the
backend, so every load attached two viewers to a one-socket printer. The src
now waits for the token query to settle.

Subscribers only checked for client disconnect after yielding a frame or on a
30s idle timeout, so a viewer that left during a black stream stayed counted —
and /camera/stop trusts that count to decide whether to tear the upstream down.
2026-07-14 11:52:56 +02:00

587 lines
22 KiB
Python

"""Unit tests for the MJPEG fan-out broadcaster (#1089).
These tests do not touch ffmpeg or any printer — they drive a fake upstream
generator and assert subscriber/pump lifecycle behaviour.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import asyncio
from collections.abc import AsyncGenerator
import pytest
from backend.app.services import camera_fanout
from backend.app.services.camera_fanout import (
MjpegBroadcaster,
get_or_create_broadcaster,
iter_subscriber,
shutdown_all_broadcasters,
shutdown_broadcaster,
)
pytestmark = pytest.mark.asyncio
# Speed up grace-window tests so the suite stays fast. The default 5s grace
# is overkill for unit tests; we patch it down to a few ms.
@pytest.fixture(autouse=True)
def _short_grace(monkeypatch):
monkeypatch.setattr(camera_fanout, "_GRACE_SECONDS", 0.05)
@pytest.fixture(autouse=True)
async def _clean_registry():
"""Reset the global broadcaster registry between tests."""
await shutdown_all_broadcasters()
yield
await shutdown_all_broadcasters()
def _make_factory(
chunks: list[bytes],
*,
delay: float = 0.0,
pump_started: asyncio.Event | None = None,
pump_count: list[int] | None = None,
):
"""Build an upstream factory that yields a fixed list of chunks."""
async def factory(disconnect: asyncio.Event) -> AsyncGenerator[bytes, None]:
if pump_started is not None:
pump_started.set()
if pump_count is not None:
pump_count[0] += 1
for chunk in chunks:
if disconnect.is_set():
return
if delay:
try:
await asyncio.wait_for(disconnect.wait(), timeout=delay)
return
except asyncio.TimeoutError:
pass
yield chunk
return factory
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Single subscriber
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_single_subscriber_receives_all_frames():
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory([b"a", b"b", b"c"], delay=0.005))
queue = await bc.subscribe()
received = []
for _ in range(3):
received.append(await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=1.0))
assert received == [b"a", b"b", b"c"]
await bc.force_shutdown()
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Multiple subscribers share one upstream
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_multiple_subscribers_share_single_upstream():
pump_count = [0]
bc = MjpegBroadcaster(
"p1",
_make_factory([b"f1", b"f2", b"f3"], delay=0.01, pump_count=pump_count),
)
q1 = await bc.subscribe()
q2 = await bc.subscribe()
q3 = await bc.subscribe()
# Each subscriber must receive each frame exactly once.
for q in (q1, q2, q3):
received = []
for _ in range(3):
received.append(await asyncio.wait_for(q.get(), timeout=1.0))
assert received == [b"f1", b"f2", b"f3"]
# Only ONE upstream pump ever ran — that is the entire point of the bug fix.
assert pump_count[0] == 1
await bc.force_shutdown()
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Late subscribers are primed with the last frame (#2521)
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_late_subscriber_primed_with_last_frame():
"""A viewer that joins after the stream is running must receive the most
recent frame immediately, not wait for the next upstream frame. On slow
chamber-image cams that wait looked like a permanent black screen (#2521).
"""
async def factory(disconnect: asyncio.Event) -> AsyncGenerator[bytes, None]:
yield b"first"
await disconnect.wait() # then hold the stream open, no further frames
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", factory)
q1 = await bc.subscribe()
# First subscriber consumes the frame; this also guarantees the pump has
# recorded it as the last chunk.
assert await asyncio.wait_for(q1.get(), timeout=1.0) == b"first"
# Late joiner is handed that frame at once, even though no new frame is coming.
q2 = await bc.subscribe()
assert await asyncio.wait_for(q2.get(), timeout=0.2) == b"first"
await bc.force_shutdown()
async def test_first_subscriber_not_primed():
"""The very first subscriber has no prior frame to be primed with — its
queue starts empty and it triggers the upstream connect.
"""
async def factory(disconnect: asyncio.Event) -> AsyncGenerator[bytes, None]:
await disconnect.wait() # never produces a frame
yield b"never" # pragma: no cover
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", factory)
q1 = await bc.subscribe()
await asyncio.sleep(0) # let the pump start
assert q1.empty()
await bc.force_shutdown()
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Slow subscriber should not block fast subscribers
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_slow_subscriber_does_not_block_others():
# Generate more frames than the queue depth so a non-draining queue is
# guaranteed to fill up.
chunks = [bytes([i % 256]) for i in range(50)]
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory(chunks, delay=0.001))
slow = await bc.subscribe()
fast = await bc.subscribe()
# Drain `fast` quickly; never read from `slow`. The fast subscriber must
# still get every frame even though `slow` is wedged.
received_fast = []
for _ in range(50):
received_fast.append(await asyncio.wait_for(fast.get(), timeout=2.0))
assert received_fast == chunks
# Slow subscriber's queue should be at most _SUBSCRIBER_QUEUE_SIZE — older
# frames were dropped, not stuffed indefinitely.
assert slow.qsize() <= camera_fanout._SUBSCRIBER_QUEUE_SIZE
await bc.force_shutdown()
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Last-subscriber-leaves grace window
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_pump_torn_down_after_last_subscriber_leaves(monkeypatch):
monkeypatch.setattr(camera_fanout, "_GRACE_SECONDS", 0.05)
pump_count = [0]
# Long upstream so we know it's still running until disconnect signals it.
bc = MjpegBroadcaster(
"p1",
_make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.05, pump_count=pump_count),
)
queue = await bc.subscribe()
# Read a couple of frames.
await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=1.0)
await bc.unsubscribe(queue)
# Wait for grace window to elapse + a hair more.
await asyncio.sleep(0.2)
assert bc.subscriber_count == 0
assert bc.stopped is True
assert pump_count[0] == 1
async def test_grace_window_cancelled_on_rejoin(monkeypatch):
monkeypatch.setattr(camera_fanout, "_GRACE_SECONDS", 0.1)
pump_count = [0]
bc = MjpegBroadcaster(
"p1",
_make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.02, pump_count=pump_count),
)
q1 = await bc.subscribe()
await asyncio.wait_for(q1.get(), timeout=1.0)
await bc.unsubscribe(q1)
# Rejoin BEFORE grace expires — pump should keep running.
await asyncio.sleep(0.02)
q2 = await bc.subscribe()
# Settle past the original grace deadline.
await asyncio.sleep(0.2)
# Pump still alive, only one upstream connection ever opened.
assert bc.stopped is False
assert pump_count[0] == 1
# And the second subscriber is still receiving frames.
await asyncio.wait_for(q2.get(), timeout=1.0)
await bc.force_shutdown()
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Force shutdown wakes subscribers
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_force_shutdown_signals_subscribers():
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.05))
queue = await bc.subscribe()
await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=1.0)
await bc.force_shutdown()
# Subscriber's queue should contain the upstream-gone sentinel (or be
# drained); either way a get() must complete promptly.
sentinel = await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=1.0)
assert sentinel == camera_fanout._UPSTREAM_GONE
assert bc.stopped is True
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# iter_subscriber helper exits cleanly on upstream-gone and disconnect
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_iter_subscriber_exits_on_upstream_gone():
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory([b"a", b"b"], delay=0.005))
queue = await bc.subscribe()
received = []
async for chunk in iter_subscriber(bc, queue):
received.append(chunk)
# Pump exited after yielding two chunks; iter_subscriber must return.
assert received == [b"a", b"b"]
# Helper unsubscribed us on the way out.
assert bc.subscriber_count == 0
async def test_iter_subscriber_exits_on_client_disconnect():
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.02))
queue = await bc.subscribe()
seen = 0
async def is_disconnected() -> bool:
return seen >= 2 # Pretend the client left after 2 frames.
async for _chunk in iter_subscriber(bc, queue, is_disconnected=is_disconnected):
seen += 1
if seen >= 5: # Defensive cap so a buggy iterator can't run forever.
break
assert seen == 2
assert bc.subscriber_count == 0
await bc.force_shutdown()
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Registry: stopped broadcasters get replaced
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_registry_replaces_stopped_broadcaster():
factory_a = _make_factory([b"a"] * 1000, delay=0.02)
factory_b = _make_factory([b"b"] * 1000, delay=0.02)
bc1 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory_a)
q1 = await bc1.subscribe()
await asyncio.wait_for(q1.get(), timeout=1.0)
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
assert bc1.stopped is True
# New subscription must get a fresh broadcaster.
bc2 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory_b)
assert bc2 is not bc1
q2 = await bc2.subscribe()
chunk = await asyncio.wait_for(q2.get(), timeout=1.0)
assert chunk == b"b"
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Audit findings: subscribe-after-grace-stops contract + unsubscribe count
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_subscribe_to_stopped_raises_so_route_can_retry():
"""Contract: subscribe() raises RuntimeError when called on a stopped
broadcaster. The route relies on this signal to re-fetch the registry
entry (which will then mint a fresh broadcaster) instead of subscribing
to a corpse.
"""
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory([b"x"], delay=0.005))
await bc.force_shutdown()
assert bc.stopped is True
with pytest.raises(RuntimeError):
await bc.subscribe()
async def test_unsubscribe_returns_remaining_count_atomically():
"""Two subscribers leaving simultaneously must report distinct remaining
counts (1 then 0), not both report 0 due to a race between unsubscribe
and reading subscriber_count after the fact.
"""
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.05))
q1 = await bc.subscribe()
q2 = await bc.subscribe()
# Run both unsubscribes concurrently. Each should return its own
# post-removal count.
counts = await asyncio.gather(bc.unsubscribe(q1), bc.unsubscribe(q2))
assert sorted(counts) == [0, 1], f"expected one unsubscribe to see 1 remaining and the other to see 0, got {counts}"
await bc.force_shutdown()
async def test_unsubscribe_idempotent_returns_current_count():
"""Double-unsubscribe (e.g. shutdown raced with iter_subscriber finally)
must not corrupt state; second call returns whatever the count is now.
"""
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.05))
q1 = await bc.subscribe()
await bc.subscribe() # q2 stays subscribed; we only care about removal of q1
first = await bc.unsubscribe(q1)
again = await bc.unsubscribe(q1) # already gone
assert first == 1
assert again == 1 # q2 is still there
await bc.force_shutdown()
async def test_force_shutdown_then_subscribe_via_registry_works():
"""Simulates the route's retry path: a viewer calls subscribe(), gets
RuntimeError, calls get_or_create_broadcaster again, and successfully
subscribes to the fresh broadcaster.
"""
factory = _make_factory([b"hello"] * 1000, delay=0.02)
bc1 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
# Mark the registered broadcaster stopped to simulate the grace teardown
# winning the race against a new subscriber.
await bc1.force_shutdown()
# First subscribe attempt would raise on bc1; the registry replaces it.
bc2 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
assert bc2 is not bc1
queue = await bc2.subscribe()
chunk = await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=1.0)
assert chunk == b"hello"
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# Teardown barrier: replacement waits for the prior upstream socket to close
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
async def test_wait_until_torn_down_completes_after_force_shutdown():
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.05))
await bc.subscribe()
await bc.force_shutdown()
# Fully torn down → the barrier returns promptly.
await asyncio.wait_for(bc.wait_until_torn_down(), timeout=1.0)
async def test_successor_pump_waits_for_predecessor_socket_close():
"""A replacement broadcaster's pump must not dial the printer until the
displaced (stopped) one's socket has finished closing — otherwise a
single-connection printer briefly sees two sockets and strands frames on
the orphaned one (#2521). Guarding at the pump (not at get_or_create) keeps
it correct even when concurrent viewers race to replace the same corpse.
Drive the mid-teardown state directly so the test is deterministic.
"""
factory = _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.02)
bc1 = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", factory)
# Register it and simulate "grace fired: stopped, but socket not yet closed".
camera_fanout._broadcasters["p1"] = bc1
bc1._stopped = True # noqa: SLF001 — white-box: mid-teardown snapshot
assert not bc1._teardown_complete.is_set() # noqa: SLF001
# get_or_create returns immediately with the successor chained to bc1.
bc2 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
assert bc2 is not bc1
# Subscribing starts bc2's pump, but it must block on bc1's teardown before
# producing any frame.
queue = await bc2.subscribe()
await asyncio.sleep(0.03)
assert queue.empty(), "successor produced a frame before the prior upstream closed"
# Predecessor teardown completes → bc2's pump dials and frames flow.
bc1._teardown_complete.set() # noqa: SLF001
assert await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=1.0) == b"x"
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
async def test_successor_pump_times_out_if_predecessor_wedges(monkeypatch):
"""If a displaced broadcaster's teardown never completes, the successor's
pump must dial anyway (bounded wait) rather than never producing a frame.
"""
monkeypatch.setattr(camera_fanout, "_TEARDOWN_WAIT_SECONDS", 0.05)
factory = _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.02)
bc1 = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", factory)
camera_fanout._broadcasters["p1"] = bc1
bc1._stopped = True # noqa: SLF001 — wedged mid-teardown, event never set
# teardown_complete intentionally never set.
bc2 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
assert bc2 is not bc1
queue = await bc2.subscribe()
# After the bounded wait elapses the pump dials and delivers a frame.
assert await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=1.0) == b"x"
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
# The printer only has ONE camera socket (#2521)
# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
def _socket_counting_factory(state: dict, *, close_delay: float = 0.05):
"""Upstream factory that models a real TCP socket to the printer.
Records the peak number of simultaneously-open sockets. A chamber-image cam
(P1/A1, port 6000) accepts exactly one connection: when a second overlaps,
the printer keeps feeding the first and the newcomer never sees a frame —
until the printer's TCP keepalive reaps the orphan, ~20 minutes later.
"""
async def factory(disconnect: asyncio.Event) -> AsyncGenerator[bytes, None]:
await asyncio.sleep(0.01) # dial + TLS handshake
state["open"] += 1
state["peak"] = max(state["peak"], state["open"])
try:
while not disconnect.is_set():
await asyncio.sleep(0.01)
yield b"frame"
finally:
await asyncio.sleep(close_delay) # TCP close is not instantaneous
state["open"] -= 1
return factory
async def test_stop_then_restream_never_opens_two_sockets():
"""A page reload fires POST /camera/stop and GET /camera/stream at the same
time. ``shutdown_broadcaster`` used to *pop* the broadcaster out of the
registry and only then await its teardown, so a stream request landing in
that window found an empty slot, minted a broadcaster with no predecessor,
and dialled the printer while the old socket was still closing (#2521).
"""
state = {"open": 0, "peak": 0}
factory = _socket_counting_factory(state)
bc1 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
queue = await bc1.subscribe()
assert await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=1.0) == b"frame"
await bc1.unsubscribe(queue)
async def viewer_unmount_stop():
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
async def reloaded_page_streams():
await asyncio.sleep(0.005) # lands a hair after the stop
bc = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
q = await bc.subscribe()
return await asyncio.wait_for(q.get(), timeout=2.0)
_stop_result, frame = await asyncio.gather(viewer_unmount_stop(), reloaded_page_streams())
assert frame == b"frame", "the reloaded page's viewer never received a frame"
assert state["peak"] == 1, (
f"opened {state['peak']} concurrent sockets to a printer that allows one — "
"the new stream dialled before the old socket closed"
)
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
async def test_shutdown_broadcaster_leaves_a_chainable_predecessor():
"""The stopped broadcaster must stay findable in the registry: that is what
lets the next viewer's pump chain behind its socket close."""
state = {"open": 0, "peak": 0}
factory = _socket_counting_factory(state)
bc1 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
await bc1.subscribe()
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
assert camera_fanout._broadcasters.get("p1") is bc1, ( # noqa: SLF001
"the stopped broadcaster was removed from the registry — a successor "
"created now would have predecessor=None and dial immediately"
)
bc2 = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
assert bc2._predecessor is bc1 # noqa: SLF001 — white-box: the chain is the fix
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
async def test_shutdown_broadcaster_is_idempotent():
"""/camera/stop can fire twice (unmount + beforeunload). The second call
must report nothing was running rather than tearing down a live successor."""
factory = _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.02)
bc = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
await bc.subscribe()
assert await shutdown_broadcaster("p1") is True
assert await shutdown_broadcaster("p1") is False
assert await shutdown_broadcaster("never-existed") is False
async def test_stopped_broadcaster_reports_no_subscribers():
"""/camera/stop's reference-count guard must not see the corpse's leftovers."""
from backend.app.services.camera_fanout import get_subscriber_count
factory = _make_factory([b"x"] * 1000, delay=0.02)
bc = await get_or_create_broadcaster("p1", factory)
await bc.subscribe()
assert get_subscriber_count("p1") == 1
await shutdown_broadcaster("p1")
assert get_subscriber_count("p1") == 0, "a stopped broadcaster still reported subscribers"
async def test_subscriber_with_no_frames_detaches_promptly():
"""A viewer that goes away while the stream is black must stop being counted.
The disconnect check only ran after a chunk was yielded, or on a 30 s idle
timeout — so a client that left during a black stream stayed *counted* as a
subscriber for up to half a minute. /camera/stop trusts that count to decide
whether to tear the upstream down, so a phantom subscriber could make it
skip teardown entirely (#2521).
"""
async def silent_factory(disconnect: asyncio.Event) -> AsyncGenerator[bytes, None]:
await disconnect.wait() # connected, but the printer sends nothing
return
yield # pragma: no cover — makes this an async generator
bc = MjpegBroadcaster("p1", silent_factory)
queue = await bc.subscribe()
assert bc.subscriber_count == 1
async def is_disconnected() -> bool:
return True # the browser aborted the request
async def drain():
async for _chunk in iter_subscriber(bc, queue, is_disconnected=is_disconnected):
pass
# Must notice well inside the old 30 s idle timeout.
await asyncio.wait_for(drain(), timeout=3.0)
assert bc.subscriber_count == 0
await bc.force_shutdown()